Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.
- HGThe agents and staff at Preferred Insurance do an incredible job in customer...Haley G., La Crosse, Wisconsin
“The agents and staff at Preferred Insurance do an incredible job in customer service, communication, and saving people money! I had one of their agents (Peter Olson) run me a free quote to compare with my current auto insurance and Peter got back to me within a few hours with a quote that was the same company and coverage but $480 cheaper per year. 5/5 recommend!”
- KMHad an auto quote within 30 minutes from Tony! He was extremely responsive and...Kylie M., La Crosse, Wisconsin
“Had an auto quote within 30 minutes from Tony! He was extremely responsive and was lower in price than anywhere else I shopped! Even my car dealer was impressed with the rate I got and she deals with auto insurance every day!”
Tony and his crew are amazing! Offer amazing rates and better customer service....Spenser N., La Crosse, Wisconsin“Tony and his crew are amazing! Offer amazing rates and better customer service. Do yourself a favor and call them today!”
- RRPreferred Insurance is the best insurance company. They were able to save me...Rachel R., La Crosse, Wisconsin
“Preferred Insurance is the best insurance company. They were able to save me money on my home and auto insurance. I would highly recommend Tony Rausa at Preferred Insurance in La Crosse, WI.”
- BJAnthony Rausa made my switch simple and easy! Also the rates were great! ...Ben J., La Crosse, Wisconsin
“Anthony Rausa made my switch simple and easy! Also the rates were great! Thanks Tony!”
- I was so blown away when I learned how much Tony could save me on my car...Peter O., La Crosse, Wisconsin
“I was so blown away when I learned how much Tony could save me on my car insurance, that I decided to become an agent myself in order to help others get the most value for their insurance dollars. DON’T PAY MORE THAN YOU HAVE TO!!!”
- Amazing! The service is like no other agency out there. They truly care!...Todd V., La Crosse, Wisconsin
“Amazing! The service is like no other agency out there. They truly care! Amazing products and prices! Saved me a ton and plus better coverage! Preferred for life! Boom!”
- JLI switched my homeowners, auto and several rental policies several years ago,...Justin L., La Crosse, Wisconsin
“I switched my homeowners, auto and several rental policies several years ago, and it was one of the best financial decisions I’ve ever made. Not only did my premiums go down in price, my coverages went up! In addition to that, the service and attention that I received during the claim process on both a car and house was better than I had ever experienced. I highly recommend Tony and his team at Prefered Insurance.”
- Largely unbeatable rates.Sam S., Onalaska, WI
“Largely unbeatable rates. Tony is an awesome guy too. Makes doing business with Preferred Insurance EASY.”
- Saved me $534 with better coverage!Charlene H., La Crosse, WI
“Saved me $534 with better coverage! Love this company!!!”
- BBBarb B., La Crosse, Wisconsin
“Highly recommend preferred insurance,, they are the best!!”
- BBrandy, La Crosse, Wisconsin
“Scott was professional, friendly and made it easy to figure out what direction to go with my insurance for 2026.”
- SSSamantha S., La Crosse, Wisconsin
“Tony has done a great job helping us find better deals on our insurance plans. Was very helpful when my vehicle was in an accident. Very prompt and communicates well. Walked me through everything that needed to be done when I had my first accident.”
- PSPaul S., La Crosse, Wisconsin
“Needed renters insurance quickly when our apartment complex changed their rules and required it by the end of the month. Preferred got us set up and done with one phone call, and the policy has triple the coverage for half the price that the apartment’s default provider offered. Five stars!”
- Alex B., La Crosse, Wisconsin
“Friendly, helpful, and professional. We needed a quote back within a 24 hour window, and they made it happen.”
